Article · Wikipedia archive · Last revised Jul 23, 2026

Most Requested Hits

Most Requested Hits is American teen pop singer Aaron Carter's first compilation album and fourth overall album under Jive Records. The compilation includes no tracks from Carter's self-titled debut album, and was released on November 3, 2003. The album was initially announced with an accompanying DVD, but it was later cancelled by Jive due to technical issues.

Last revised
Jul 23, 2026
Read time
≈ 3 min
Length
596 w
Citations
8
Source
Wikipedia ↗
Most Requested Hits
Greatest hits album by
Aaron Carter
ReleasedNovember 3, 2003
Recorded2000–2003
GenresTeen pop, pop rap, dance-pop
Length54:56
LabelJive
Aaron Carter chronology
Another Earthquake!
(2002) 		Most Requested Hits
(2003) 		Come Get It: The Very Best of Aaron Carter
(2006)
Singles from Most Requested Hits
  1. "She Wants Me"
    Released: 2003
  2. "One Better"
    Released: November 3, 2003

Most Requested Hits is American teen pop singer Aaron Carter's first compilation album and fourth overall album under Jive Records. The compilation includes no tracks from Carter's self-titled debut album,1 and was released on November 3, 2003.2 The album was initially announced with an accompanying DVD, but it was later cancelled by Jive due to technical issues.3

Critical reception

Professional ratings
Review scores
SourceRating
AllMusicStarStarStarHalf star4

Neil Strauss of The New York Times wrote that Aaron Carter's early hits "must make him cringe", and added that "they make me cringe".5 Adam Tod Brown of Cracked mocked the album's premise, questioning the title with, "Most requested hits? Requested by who?" and sarcastically suggesting that a "Freedom of Information Act request is pending" to see the supposed data. He highlighted "That's How I Beat Shaq" as the "Best Moment".6

Stephen Thomas Erlewine of AllMusic argued that although Most Requested Hits suggests a comprehensive roundup, "not a lot of hits" justified such a compilation, noting that "'Shake It' has been left off, as is anything from his 1998 debut". He observed that Aaron was "trying to present himself as a young adult" and highlighted material from Another Earthquake!, concluding that the album becomes "an interesting listen", since it "winds up having contrast and a narrative", even if it "doesn't have all of his hits".4

Track listing

Most Requested Hits track listing
No.TitleWriter(s)AlbumLength
1."Aaron's Party (Come Get It)"B. Kierulf; J. SchwartzAaron's Party (Come Get It)3:25
2."I Want Candy"Bert Berns; Gerald Goldstein; Richard Gottehrer; Robert FeldmanAaron's Party (Come Get It)3:14
3."That's How I Beat Shaq"B. Kierulf; J. SchwartzAaron's Party (Come Get It)3:25
4."Oh Aaron" (featuring Nick Carter and No Secrets)Andy Goldmark; B. Kierulf; J. SchwartzOh Aaron3:17
5."Not Too Young, Not Too Old" (featuring Nick Carter)A. Lindsey; L. Palmer; L. Secon; M. Power; S. Williams; V. RaeburnOh Aaron3:08
6."I'm All About You"Andy Goldmark; M. MuellerOh Aaron3:41
7."Leave It Up to Me"L. Secon; M. PowerJimmy Neutron: Boy Genius soundtrack2:59
8."Another Earthquake"L. Secon; M. PowerAnother Earthquake!2:51
9."To All the Girls"K. Giola; Rich Cronin; SheppardAnother Earthquake!3:26
10."Summertime" (featuring Baha Men)Martin Bushell; N. Cook; Tony MomrelleAnother Earthquake!3:50
11."Do You Remember"D. O'Donoghue; M. Mueller; M. SheehanAnother Earthquake!3:58
12."America A O"Alan Ross; L. Secon; M. PowerAnother Earthquake!3:30
13."She Wants Me" (featuring Nick Carter)J. CoplanNew track3:43
14."One Better"A. Carter; B. Kierulf; J. SchwartzNew track3:29
15."My Shorty"A. Theodore; M. SandloferNew track3:41
16."One Better (Remix)" (Hidden bonus track)A. Carter; B. Kierulf; J. SchwartzNew track3:19

Charts

Weekly chart performance for Most Requested Hits
Chart (2003) Peak
position
Japanese Albums Chart7 160
References

References

  1. "Aaron's New Album - "Most Requested Hits"". aaroncarter.com. November 2003. Archived from the original on December 16, 2003. Retrieved September 29, 2012.
  2. Iasimone, Ashley (November 6, 2022). "Aaron Carter's Career Timeline: From 'Crush on You' and 'Aaron's Party' to Broadway, TV and 'Love'". Billboard. Archived from the original on November 24, 2022. Retrieved February 14, 2026.
  3. "Most requested hits DVD missing". AaronCarter.com - Aaron's Official Web Site. November 25, 2003. Archived from the original on December 8, 2003. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  4. Stephen Thomas Erlewine (November 2003). "AllMusic Review:Aaron Carter's Most Requested Hits". www.allmusic.com. Retrieved September 29, 2012.
  5. Strauss, Neil (December 5, 2003). "Greatest Hits, Live Albums And Compilations; AARON CARTER". The New York Times (Online). New York: New York Times Company. ISSN 1553-8095. ProQuest 2229565966.
  6. "The 9 Most Unnecessary Greatest Hits Albums of All Time". Cracked. Demand Media. Retrieved January 8, 2016.
  7. Oricon Archive - past 2003 release date - Most Requested Hits Retrieved January 8, 2016