Article · Wikipedia archive · Last revised Jun 19, 2026

1991 Major League Baseball draft

The 1991 Major League Baseball draft began 3 June 1991 to assign amateur baseball players to MLB teams. The draft order is the reverse order of the 1990 MLB season standings. In addition, compensation picks will be distributed for players who did not sign from the 1990 MLB Draft. The New York Yankees received the first overall selection.

Last revised
Jun 19, 2026
Read time
≈ 11 min
Length
2,597 w
Citations
23
Source
1991 Major League Baseball draft
General information
DateJune 3, 1991
LocationConference call
Overview
1,301 total selections
First selectionBrien Taylor
New York Yankees
First round selections44
Hall of Famers0

The 1991 Major League Baseball draft began 3 June 1991 to assign amateur baseball players to MLB teams. The draft order is the reverse order of the 1990 MLB season standings. In addition, compensation picks will be distributed for players who did not sign from the 1990 MLB Draft. The New York Yankees received the first overall selection.

Brien Taylor would become only the second top pick to fail to reach the major leagues, following Steve Chilcott of the 1966 draft.1

First round selections

The following are the first-round picks in the 1991 Major League Baseball draft.

= All-Star = Baseball Hall of Famer
Pick Player Team Position Hometown/School
1 Brien Taylor New York Yankees Pitcher East Carteret High School (NC)
2 Mike Kelly Atlanta Braves Outfielder Arizona State
3 David McCarty Minnesota Twins First Baseman Stanford
4 Dmitri Young St. Louis Cardinals Third Baseman Rio Mesa High School (CA)
5 Kenny Henderson Milwaukee Brewers Pitcher Ringgold High School (GA)
6 John Burke Houston Astros Pitcher Florida
7 Joe Vitiello Kansas City Royals Outfielder Alabama
8 Joey Hamilton San Diego Padres Pitcher Georgia Southern
9 Mark Smith Baltimore Orioles Outfielder USC
10 Tyler Green Philadelphia Phillies Pitcher Wichita State
11 Shawn Estes Seattle Mariners Pitcher Douglas High School (NV)
12 Doug Glanville Chicago Cubs Outfielder Pennsylvania
13 Manny Ramirez Cleveland Indians Outfielder George Washington High School (NY)
14 Cliff Floyd Montreal Expos First Baseman Thornwood High School (IL)
15 Tyrone Hill Milwaukee BrewersCompensation 1 Pitcher Yucaipa High School (CA)
16 Shawn Green Toronto Blue JaysCompensation 2 Outfielder Tustin High School (CA)
17 Eduardo Pérez California Angels First Baseman Florida State
18 Al Shirley New York MetsCompensation 3 Outfielder George Washington High School (VA)
19 Benji Gil Texas Rangers Shortstop Castle Park High School (CA)
20 Pokey Reese Cincinnati Reds Shortstop Lower Richland High School (SC)
21 Allen Watson St. Louis CardinalsCompensation 4 Pitcher New York Institute of Technology
22 Brian Barber St. Louis CardinalsCompensation 5 Pitcher Dr. Phillips High School (FL)
23 Aaron Sele Boston Red Sox Pitcher Washington State
24 Jon Farrell Pittsburgh Pirates Catcher Florida Junior College
25 Scott Ruffcorn Chicago White Sox Pitcher Baylor
26 Brent Gates Oakland Athletics Shortstop Minnesota

Supplemental first round selections

Pick Player Team Position Hometown/School
27 Scott Stahoviak Minnesota TwinsCompensation 6 Third Baseman Creighton
28 Tom McKinnon Saint Louis CardinalsCompensation 7 Pitcher Jordan High School (CA)
29 Shawn Livsey Houston AstrosCompensation 8 Shortstop Simeon High School (IL)
30 Jason Pruitt Kansas City RoyalsCompensation 9 Pitcher Rockingham County High School (NC)
31 Greg Anthony San Diego PadresCompensation 10 Pitcher Tavares High School (FL)
32 Justin Thompson Detroit TigersCompensation 11 Pitcher Klein Oak High School (TX)
33 Steve Whitaker San Francisco GiantsCompensation 12 Pitcher Long Beach State
34 Jorge Fábregas California AngelsCompensation 13 Third Baseman Miami (FL)
35 Jeff Ware Toronto Blue JaysCompensation 14 Pitcher Old Dominion
36 Bobby Jones New York MetsCompensation 15 Pitcher Fresno State
37 J.J. Johnson Boston Red SoxCompensation 16 Outfielder Pine Plains High School (NY)
38 Mike Rossiter Oakland AthleticsCompensation 17 Pitcher Burroughs High School (CA)
39 Dan Cholowsky St. Louis CardinalsCompensation 18 Third Baseman California
40 Jim Gonzalez Houston Astros Catcher East Hartford High School (CT)
41 Trever Miller Detroit TigersCompensation 19 Pitcher Trinity High School (KY)
42 Dante Powell Toronto Blue JaysCompensation 20 Outfield Millikan High School (CA)
43 Scott Hatteberg Boston Red Sox Catcher Washington State
44 Mike Groppuso Houston AstrosCompensation 21 Third Baseman Seton Hall

2

Compensation picks

  1. Compensation pick from the Detroit Tigers for signing Rob Deer
  2. Compensation pick from the San Francisco Giants for signing Bud Black
  3. Compensation pick from the Los Angeles Dodgers for signing Darryl Strawberry
  4. Compensation pick from the Toronto Blue Jays for signing Ken Dayley
  5. Compensation pick from the New York Mets for signing Vince Coleman
  6. Supplemental pick for loss of free agent Gary Gaetti
  7. Supplemental pick for loss of free agent Terry Pendleton
  8. Supplemental pick for loss of free agent Danny Darwin
  9. Supplemental pick for loss of free agent Steve Farr
  10. Supplemental pick for loss of free agent Jack Clark
  11. Supplemental pick for loss of free agent Jack Morris
  12. Supplemental pick for loss of free agent Brett Butler
  13. Supplemental pick for loss of free agent Chili Davis
  14. Supplemental pick for loss of free agent George Bell
  15. Supplemental pick for loss of free agent Darryl Strawberry
  16. Supplemental pick for loss of free agent Larry Andersen
  17. Supplemental pick for loss of free agent Willie McGee
  18. Supplemental pick for loss of free agent Ken Dayley
  19. Supplemental pick for loss of free agent Mike Heath
  20. Supplemental pick for loss of free agent Buddy Black
  21. Supplemental pick for loss of free agent Franklin Stubbs

Other notable players

NFL players drafted

External links
References

References

  1. Schlegel, John; Eagle, Ed (July 15, 2022). "These top-3 Draft picks never made MLB". MLB.com. Major League Baseball. Retrieved May 15, 2024.
  2. Baseball-Reference.com Draft Database